Mr Johnson was a civil servant until he was made redundant in April 2007. At the time of redundancy he was aged 57 years and one month. He was entitled to a lump-sum payment of six months’ final pensionable pay under the Civil Service Compensation Scheme (CSCS). Under the CSCS rules, payments were tapered progressively for those aged…
-
This case was an appeal from the EAT. For details of the facts and a summary of that decision, click here. Ms Lockwood’s case was appealed to the Court of Appeal. The main issue was to consider whether her circumstances were materially different from the comparator and if so, whether there was an objective justification for…
-
On reaching the retirement age of 50 under Air Product Plc’s (“APP”) defined benefit pension scheme Mr Cockram left APP and started to take his pension. During his employment Mr Cockram had received stock options under APP’s Long Term Incentive Plan (“LTIP”). Some were vested and some were unvested at the point of Mr Cockram’s…
-
Mrs Edie was part of a group of a number of employees whose employment transferred to HCL Insurance BPO services Ltd (“HCL”) following a TUPE transfer. HCL sought to bring in measures to harmonise the terms of its employees and to improve its profitability. HCL attempted to negotiate terms with its staff, but unilaterally imposed…
-
Hungarian law allowed judges, prosecutors and notaries to work until 70. At age 70, they would be retired. On 1 January 2012, the retirement age was lowered to 62. Transitional provisions were in place, meaning that those already older than 62 would be retired on 30 June 2012. Those who would reach 62 during 2012…
-
In March 2012 the London Borough of Barnet Council (“Barnet”) approved planning permission for a primary school. The proposed site had been used by the local community for over eighty years, and as a garden centre for the last twenty. The garden centre ran workshops, activities and horticultural lessons for local residents, but had to…
-
Barking and Dagenham Council loses appeal after 15 employees bring age discrimination claim. A change from one policy to another policy cannot in itself be a provision, criterion or practice for the purposes of the Age Regulations. A former Council employee is successful in possibly the highest value age discrimination claim to date The EAT…
-
The ECJ has held that a collective agreement prohibiting airline pilots from working after the age of 60 is incompatible with EU law and constitutes age discrimination. In these joined decisions, the ECJ has held that a term in a collective agreement which provides that the pay of a public sector employee is determined by…
-
The full facts can be found in our summaries of the Employment Appeal Tribunal decision (“EAT”) and the original Employment Tribunal decision (“ET”). In summary, they are as follows. Mr Woodcock was Chief Executive of North Cumbria Primary Care Trust (“the Trust”) and was made redundant following the merger of a number of Primary Care Trusts in…
-
Mr Methuen, a 54 year old Asian man, worked at the Family department of Community Law Clinic Solicitors Ltd (“CLC”), but was dismissed. His replacement was a 34 year old Afro-Caribbean woman. Mr Methuen brought claims in the ET for direct race, sex and age discrimination. CLC argued that the differences in protected characteristics that…
